12 Apr

Conservation of Choice: Simplifying Investment Options to Better Serve Participants

Arnerich Massena & Associates, Inc.
April 2010
Contributors:
Tony Arnerich; Howard Biggs; Vincent Galindo; Jacob O’Shaughnessy, CFA; Jillian Perkins

https://www.am-a.com/company/research/wp_participantchoice.pdf

“In our last analysis, we found that between 1995 and 2006, DB [defined benefit] plans outperformed DC [defined contribution] plans by an average of 1 percentage point per year. Earlier studies also found that, over time, DB plans attained higher returns than 401(k) plans. In this year’s analysis, the results remain in line with past analyses; DB plans outperform DC plans by roughly an average of 1 percentage point a year.”
– “Defined Benefit vs. 401(k) Investment Returns: The 2006-2008 Update” Insider, Watson Wyatt Worldwide, 2009

As we watch assets in defined benefit plans decline relative to assets in defined contribution plans, it has become clear that American workers’ retirement security rests squarely on the shoulders of the employer-sponsored, participant-directed retirement savings plan. All parties in the retirement plan industry, from recordkeepers to advisers to plan sponsors, are cognizant of this and have enthusiastically worked to create a system that will result in retirement security for participants. Over the past decade, retirement plans have been the beneficiary of a variety of “improvements,” including bells and whistles of all sorts. Participants have been inundated with a growing spectrum of investment choices, reams of materials meant to educate and inform their investment choices, and advice to further guide their investment strategy.
So why is it that participant-directed accounts continue to underperform defined benefit accounts, regardless of the number and quality of investment options offered?
Continue reading “Conservation of Choice: Simplifying Investment Options to Better Serve Participants” »

12 Apr

New Study on 401(k): Failed Experiment or Solid Plan?

by joeplemon on April 12, 2010

From its high in October 2007 through its low in March 2009, the S & P Index fell nearly 57%. Many 401(k)s likewise plummeted drastically, forcing many to delay or scale back their retirements and bringing on the chorus of “failed experiment” in describing the 401(k) strategy. But is it?
Continue reading “New Study on 401(k): Failed Experiment or Solid Plan?” »

12 Apr

Why Your 401K and IRA Savings Could Soon Be a Prime Government Target

By Brett Owens

Retirement kiss
of death:”I’m from the guvmint”
And I’m here to help!”

Last week our local “Casey Research Phyle” got together at a local restaurant to banter about the usual talk you’d expect to overhear at such a place – like government confiscation of retirement plans, expatriation, wiring money to Central America, and our favorite shorting techniques – you know, the usual.
Continue reading “Why Your 401K and IRA Savings Could Soon Be a Prime Government Target” »

15 Mar

DoL Recovers More than $12M for Calif. Company ESOP Participants

March 11, 2010 — The U.S. Department of Labor has obtained consent judgments providing for restitution of more than $12 million by plan officials and service providers involved with the employee stock ownership plan sponsored by The Employee Ownership Holding Co. of Stockton, California, and Fife, Washington. —
Continue reading “DoL Recovers More than $12M for Calif. Company ESOP Participants” »

15 Mar

Tax Advisers Expect More than a Third of Clients to Convert to Roth

March 10, 2010 — A Fidelity Investments study found 40% of investors working with tax advisers are now eligible for Roth IRA conversions, and more than a third (35%) are expected to complete a conversion by year-end. —
Continue reading “Tax Advisers Expect More than a Third of Clients to Convert to Roth” »

23 Feb

Market Continues to Move Participants

Feb 22, 2010 — Once again, 401(k) participants that were inclined to rebalance their accounts tended to chase the market. —

And while it won’t come as a surprise to most advisers, according to the Hewitt 401(k) Index, transfers were strongly equity-oriented during the first half of the month (when markets were higher), with participants moving monies out of fixed income investments and into equities during 9 out of 10 days. However, as the market retreated mid-month, 401(k) participants also changed the direction of their transfers, and moved monies back into fixed income investments during 8 out of 9 days in the second half of the month.
Continue reading “Market Continues to Move Participants” »


© Copyright Compass Corporate Retirement Solutions 2001-2015 all rights reserved

Securities and additional advisory services offered through Independent Financial Group, LLC, a registered broker-dealer and investment advisor.OSJ Branch: 12671 High Bluff Dr. Ste 200 San Diego, CA 92130. Compass Corporate Retirement Solutions and IFG are unaffiliated entities.

Member FINRA/SIPC




Compass Corporate Retirement Solutions is a 401k and pension plan fiduciary ERISA design and plan communication specialist. Serving Houston, Dallas San Antonio and Austin, TX, Oklahoma City, OK, New Orleans, LA, Jackson, MS, Little Rock, AR.